TEI-encoded version

Elizabeth InchbaldREMARKS [on The Roman Father].1
______

William Whitehead, the author of this tragedy, was the son of a tradesman at Cambridge.2 He was admitted a scholar of Clare Hall, in that university, and afterwards obtained a fellowship.3

During the years 1754, 1755, and 1756, he accompanied the young Lords Nuneham and Villers, sons of the Earls of Harcourt and Jersey, in their travels.4 Through the patronage of these noblemen, he was, on his return, appointed Register and Secretary of the Order of the Bath.5

On the death of Colley Cibber, Mr. Whitehead became Poet Laureate.—Besides his Odes, he was author of other poetical pieces, and several dramas.6 He died at the age of seventy, in the year 1785.7

"The Roman Father" is founded on a well known event in the early part of Roman History—a combat between the Horatii and the Curiatii.8

The great Corneille had produced a tragedy on this subject some years before the present tragedy was written:9 —the English author falls infinitely beneath the French, as a poet and dramatist; though, in the character of a Roman historian, he has been perhaps more simple and faithful in the relation of facts.

But that Whitehead should omit to introduce the lover on his scene is very surprising! In the "Horace" of Corneille, Curiatius is an important character; and, though his early death in the play precludes him from b 2[Page 4]so large a share in the action, as that given to his rival in arms; still, as far as courage, joined with sensibility and tenderness, is superior to that rugged bravery, which never feels beyond its own selfish glory,—so is Curiatius, the lover in the French tragedy, superior, both as a man and a hero, to Publius Horatius, the brother.10

Although "The Roman Father" is not an exact translation from "Horace," yet, as some of the most important scenes of the first, are evidently copied from the last named play, it may be amusing to the reader to know what Corneille, in his examination of his own tragedy, has said of those parts of it which Whitehead has particularly adopted in the following pages.

The French poet commences his examination by acquainting his reader, that the drama of "Horace" would have been considered as the best among all his works, if the two last acts had equalled the three preceding.11 The reader of the English play will assuredly find a deficiency of interest towards the end of the production; and therefore the English author is, in this failure, implicated with his original.

Corneille laments, that, with all his care to describe the virtues of the brother, Horatius, as ferocious, he yet had not the art to give sufficient preparation to the audience, for the fatal effects of this young man's patriotism in the last act.12 Such may be also found Whitehead's failing.

Corneille considers it as a blemish in his play, that this event in the last act should form a double ac-[Page 5]tion, by forcing young Horatius into a second peril, after having nobly escaped the first. He calls it, besides, a meaner peril—a private quarrel, after a combat for the public weal—the fighting with a woman, after having conquered a band of heroes.

This incident it was in vain for the English writer to reject, unless he had possessed the invention to have given five acts to his play without it; and thus to have postponed the battle of Publius with the Curiatii, as Corneille says it ought to have been delayed, till the catastrophe. But as that incident, which is now introduced at the conclusion of the piece, is purely historical, and proceeds exactly from the previous grand event, it surely should be included in the tragedy, though it is to be regretted that the greater occurrence precedes the less.13

The author of "Horace" shows little gallantry to the ladies, in this his examination of the work, notwithstanding he was a Frenchman. He says, that the actress, who performed Horatia, brought on him the unjust reproach of shedding blood in the sight of an audience; for that it was set down in her part to run from her brother, with the usual cowardice of her sex, the moment he drew his sword; by which means her supposed wound would have been received behind the scenes.

In another place, he congratulates himself for having made a female the bearer of the false intelligence given in respect to the defeat of Publius;14 saying,—it was proper, on that occasion, to make use of the common impatience, and common misapprehension of a woman.b 3

Notes

1.  "Remarks." The Roman Father; A Tragedy, In Five Acts; By William Whitehead, Esq. As Performed at the Theatre Royal, Covent Garden. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers From the Prompt Book. With Remarks by Mrs. Inchbald. London: Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, Paternoster Row, pp. 3-5. The British Theatre; or, A Collection of Plays, Which Are Acted At the Theatres Royal, Drury Lane, Covent Garden, and Haymarket. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers from the Prompt Books. With Biographical and Critical Remarks, by Mrs. Inchbald. In Twenty-Five Volumes. Vol. XIV. Man of the World. Foundling. Gamester. Roman Father. Edward the Black Prince. London: Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, Paternoster Row. 1808. The first performance of this play was staged at the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane on February 24th, 1750. Laura DeWitt and Mary A. Waters edited this essay for The Criticism Archive. Back

2.  Whitehead was born and raised in the city of Cambridge in southeast England. His father was a baker of modest means who financially ruined the family due to his extravagant spending and died in 1730, when Whitehead was around the age of 15. Back

3.  In 1735, Whitehead entered Clare College at Cambridge through a scholarship which supported the orphaned sons of Cambridge bakers. He earned a BA in 1739, then to be named fellow in 1742. Back

4.  By 1745 Whitehead had the financial means to write to please rather than relying on it as his primary income. That same year, he became tutor to George Bussey Villiers, son of the third Earl of Jersey. This tutoring position required Whitehead to accompany Villers and his companion, George Simon Harcourt, son of the Earl of Harcourt, on a grand tour of Europe from 1754 to 1756. Back

5.  During his years abroad, Lady Jersey used her influence to secure multiple salaried positions for Whitehead upon his return, including secretary and registrar to the Order of the Bath as well as his 1757 appointment to the poet laureateship following the death of Colley Cibber. Back

6.  As poet laureate, Whitehead composed odes to the king twice annually until his death. His other successful plays included Creusa, Queen of Athens (1754), The School for Lovers (1762), and The Trip to Scotland (1770). Whitehead's poetry, plays, and other writings were collected in two volumes in 1774. Back

7.  Whitehead died in his home in London on April 14th, 1785, indeed at the age of 70. Back

8.  The Roman Father centers around the ancient Roman legend of the battle of the Horatii and the Curiatii, a clash between two sets of warrior triplets from Rome and Alba Longa (a neighboring city), respectively. Back

9.  Pierre Corneille's play over the same subject matter, Horace, was published in 1640 and served as the inspiration for the present play. Back

10.  In Corneille's Horace, Curiace is one of the Alban warrior triplets and fiancé of Camille, sister of the Roman warrior Horace. Curiace is revealed to have been vanquished by Horace along with his brothers in Act III, scene iv. In the present play, Publius Horatius is one of the three brother warriors from Rome and son of a prominent Senator. Publius' sister, Horatia, is engaged to Curiatius, the counterpart of Corneille's Curiace. Back

11.  Corneille's commennts on his own work can be found in Voltaire's Oeuvres De P. Corneille: Psyché. Examens Des Pièces De Corneille (Works of P. Corneille: Psyche. Examinations of Corneille's Plays, 1660). Back

12.  In the final act of Horace, the titular character murders his sister, Camille, who blames him for the death of her beloved. Back

13.  The account of Publius being the sole vanquisher of the three Curiatii warriors and subsequently murdering his sister is drawn from Livy's history. This sequence occurs in the final act of the present play, as opposed to the third act in Corneille's Horace. Back

14.  In Act III, scene i of Horace, Julia, a Roman lady and friend of Camille, brings the news that two of the Roman brothers had died and the last, Publius, had fled from the battle scene. She was misinformed; Publius only pretended to flee the battle scene to ambush the Curiatii brothers. Back